Sunday, September 8, 2019

September 8, 2019 - Proper 18C


Spirit of the Living God, fall afresh on us. Melt us, mold us, use us, fill us. Spirit of the living God, fall afresh on us. Amen.
            Nearly every Sunday, the foundation of the sermon is one of the passages of Scripture that is read. On some occasions, it might be a prayer, hymn, or part of the liturgy that the sermon is based upon. But today I’m going to preach about something that I never, ever thought that I’d preach a sermon about. Today’s sermon is about the bulletin.

            As you’ve noticed, it’s not that we’ve tweaked the bulletin, but the entire idea of what a bulletin is has been adjusted. So, for one, the sermon allows me to explain why we’ve made this change. But as I thought about it, I realized that our bulletin actually says a lot about who we are as Episcopalians and what worship in our Anglican tradition is all about.
            First, an explanation of the change. It used to be that the Sunday bulletin had most everything that you need for worship every single week. We’re still providing that information, but it’s presented differently. In the pews each week, you’ll find a liturgy guide that stays in the pews. We’ll update that document seasonally, as parts of the liturgy change. If you’re familiar with our style of worship, you might not even need to pick up that document. An exception is that we’re  using new song of praise, so at least until you learn it, you’ll need to look at it. And a note on that hymn of praise – if you don’t like it, please don’t blame our organist, Matt. It was my choice to use it. The tune, Thaxted, is absolutely gorgeous and was written by Gustov Holst and is featured in the “Jupiter” movement of my favorite symphony, The Planets. I hope that it lifts your soul as it does mine.
What the ushers will hand you is a weekly insert – it contains the information that changes week to week, so that’s where you’ll find things like hymns, readings, announcements, and schedules. The weekly insert is something that you can take home with you each week to continue reflecting on Scripture and reviewing the announcements and schedules.
            In a sense, you might say “You’ve just complicated things – instead of one bulletin, now we have two.” I’ll acknowledge that there’s no such thing as a perfect way to do bulletins. Obviously, we’re not going to install projection screens. And really, the best way to make the liturgy accessible to guests isn’t something that we can print up – it’s you. When you see someone new, even if it means not sitting in your regular pew, go over to them, welcome them, and ask “Would it be okay if I sat with you and helped you navigate our worship service?” There’s no substitute for hospitality, and so the bulletin and insert is intended to supplement your gracious help, not replace it.
            What caused me to pursue a change though was this parish’s commitment to Becoming the Beloved Community. Sometimes we use that phrase to talk about our work around racial reconciliation, sometimes we use it to talk about our own fellowship and parish life events, such as today’s parish picnic, but Beloved Community is also about our relationship to the earth. If we do not live in a beloved community with Creation, we will continue on our path of environmental destruction and unsustainability. And it’s those environmental concerns that prompted this change.
            In our previous format, we were using about 620 sheets of paper to print bulletins every single week. And a large proportion of what we were printing was duplicative every week. Yes, some things would change week to week, but a good chunk of the bulletin was just repeating the same information. That’s why we’ve changed to a format that uses only 160 sheets of paper a week, cutting our paper usage nearly in fourth. We have an environmental stewardship committee and we are committed as a parish to the work of being good stewards of God’s Creation, but using so much paper on a weekly basis simply isn’t compatible with that commitment and so something had to change.
I also want to acknowledge and sincerely and heartily thank Dawn Hamaty for her years of faithful volunteering in producing our bulletins. Truly, her generous use of time has been a blessing to this parish and having her in the office is a joy. I’m thankful that she’ll be staying on as an office volunteer. Since the new weekly insert is mostly putting together schedules and announcements, both of which Caroline Stephenson is already overseeing, it makes sense to have the same person coordinating all of that, so she’ll be producing the weekly insert going forward. So that’s the how and the why of the bulletins, but now on to what these bulletins actually say about how we understand Sunday worship.
            You all know that I’m a Biblical preacher and so, indeed, the Scripture for the day guides us. The prophet Jeremiah is speaking a word of prophecy from God to Israel and uses a metaphorical image to get the point across – we are clay and God is the potter. When I was taking classes at Sewanee in my doctoral studies, one of the classes was called “Images of God in Scripture,” and the professor’s main idea was that when Scripture gives us a symbol, the deeper we go into that symbol, the more we’ll find the power of God’s word. So, as we studied this image, w took a fieldtrip to a pottery studio to watch a woman throw a pot and learn about what God is saying through this metaphor.
            What this image of the potter tells us is that God intends to mold us, to shape us, to form us. We are not a finished product, but through the Holy Spirit, God is fashioning us as the people of God. And when you’re throwing a pot, it has to be perfected centered on the wheel, or it won’t stand up straight. And so the potter has to make sure the clay is centered. One of the primary ways that God shapes and centers us is through worship. We get the equation backwards when we think that worship is something that we do for God; instead, it is something that God gives to us in order to form us. As we participate in worship, we are fashioned as the people of God.
            Since I grew up in The Episcopal Church, I was asking my wife about what her experience of bulletins was like as she attended both Methodist and Baptist churches growing up. The answer was surprising – they didn’t really have bulletins. And so I asked, “Well, how does the congregation know what to say?” And then I realized that in many traditions, outside of hymns and maybe the Lord’s Prayer, there isn’t really much for the congregation to actively do. Now, I’m not casting judgment on how others worship, I’m simply noting that worship in The Episcopal Church is participatory. It’s not just me saying prayers, preaching, and then we sing a hymn and go home. You participate by standing, kneeling, sitting, bowing, and making the sign of the Cross at various times – and these postures all say something. You participate by saying “Amen,” not just parroting it back to me, but you say it at the end of each prayer because it’s your line, not mine. You participate in call and response at the beginning of the liturgy and at the Eucharist, and you say the Confession and Creed.
            And because our worship is participatory, there needs to be a playbook. One liturgical scholar has said that “praying shapes believing;” and it’s true. The way that we worship shapes and forms our beliefs. So the fact that we have a bulletin is a signal that the worship isn’t done for God’s benefit, but rather for ours as the liturgy teaches us about what it means to be the people of God who receive the gifts of God.
            One of the greatest hymns of all time is Charles Wesley’s “Love divine, all loves excelling,” and the last stanza sings about our ultimate worship around the throne of God and notes that we will be “lost in wonder, love, and praise.” It is through wonder, love, and praise that our Episcopal liturgy is intended to shape us. First: wonder. From today’s Psalm, “Lord, you have searched me out and known me,” or as the Collect for Purity puts it, “Almighty God, to you all hearts are open, all desires known, and from you no secrets are hid.” God knows us intimately, our sitting down and our rising up, God has marvelously made us.
And, knowing us fully, God loves us to the point of taking on flesh to bring us to abundant life, to the point of enduring the shame and agony of the Cross on account of Sin, to the point of rising from the grave to make all Creation new, and to the point of pouring out the Spirit on all flesh so that we might flourish in this love. And if that doesn’t inspire wonder, I don’t know what will. Our intentional worship is intended to remind us of God’s abundant grace. So in worship we hear the story of God’s loving purposes in Creation, of our wondrous redemption in Christ, whom we encounter in the Eucharist, and of the Spirit’s abiding presence within us. Just like the clay that is shaped by the potter, liturgy is a tool that God uses to form us in the difference that Christ makes.
Next, as Wesley’s hymn suggests, in worship, we are lost in love. That’s why I’m, perhaps stubbornly and wrongly, rejecting the trend that a lot of churches are doing with bulletins – putting every single thing in the bulletin. What happens when every word of the liturgy is printed in the bulletin is that, in addition to the high paper usage, people never touch the The Book of Common Prayer. As Episcopalians, we are people of this book. What unites us is not that we all vote the same way, not that we all think the same way, not that we all have the same preferences or lifestyles, not that we interpret Scripture in the same way, rather what unites us is that we pray together.
Our tradition is about unity, not uniformity and this unity comes not through ideology, but through our commitment to a style of worship that is held in common. And so I don’t want a bulletin to take that away, because without the foundation of the Prayer Book we lose our identity. As you are flipping to find the Nicene Creed, I want you to thumb past the Baptism and Burial, I want you to notice Confession and Catechism, I hope you find Psalms and Prayers to use in your own daily lives. Because the whole sweep of the Prayer Book tradition is about the love of God. In birth and death and everything in between, the love of God towards us is our story. Life can be hard and the world can be harsh, so our liturgies are intended to feed our souls so that we can be lost in the love of God. Our Prayer Book tradition roots the entirety of our lives in this love, and so it’s essential that we keep that tradition alive.
Finally, worship is about praise. As I said in the sermon two weeks ago, praise isn’t about the words that we say as much as it is about the orientation and posture of our lives towards God. We praise God not because God needs a pat on the back, but because we need the reminder that we are not our own creator nor are we our own savior; instead, we are dependent on God in whom we live, and move, and have our being.
Worship is sort of like dancing, if you’re thinking about your feet, you’re not quite there. As Wesley’s hymn notes, worship is about being “lost” so that we can be found and caught up in the grace of God. I was recently talking with a friend who said that his spouse, who is new to The Episcopal Church, is struggling with it because coming from a more charismatic background, it seems that there isn’t much heart in our worship. And here the image of the clay and potter is helpful. What makes the clay able to be shaped is water. Dry clay can’t be shaped, and so the potter has to continually wet the clay to make it moldable.
The waters of Baptism flow through all of our liturgies and the more that we drench ourselves in the love, belonging, blessing, and redemption expressed in Baptism, the more we will find the heart of worship and get lost in wonder, love, and praise. At its core, what we do on Sundays, and in every liturgy, is to remember and reinforce our Baptismal identity in Christ. And so it really is my prayer that these pieces of paper facilitate this experience of being shaped by God. If they get in the way, just let them be and let the liturgy wash over you as God’s grace washes over us in Baptism. If they help, use them to go deeper into the liturgy so you can get lost in wonder, love, and praise. Either way, we give thanks to God who has given us liturgy to shape us just as the potter shapes the clay, as we participate in the mystery and glory of our salvation in Jesus Christ.